Imagine unwrapping the NFL's Christmas matchups only to find they're the kind of gifts you can't wait to exchange—dull, uninspiring, and utterly disappointing. That's the harsh reality fans are facing this holiday season, and it's enough to make even the most ardent supporter question the magic of the league's festive schedule. But here's where it gets controversial: is this just a fluke of bad luck, or a sign of deeper issues plaguing the NFL's lineup? Stick around, because we're diving into why these games feel like lumps of coal rather than holiday cheer, and we might uncover some surprises along the way.
Democracy Dies in Darkness
NFL (https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/nfl/)
NFL primer: Injured quarterbacks and struggling teams are draining the excitement from the league's holiday offerings, leaving us with three matchups that simply lack the explosive energy fans crave.
Updated just now
10 min read
Analysis by Mark Maske (https://www.washingtonpost.com/people/mark-maske/)
Remember how the NFL's Thanksgiving games delivered an absolute banquet of thrilling plays and high-stakes drama? (https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2025/11/26/nfls-thanksgiving-games-this-year-are-an-absolute-feast/). Well, the Christmas slate has flipped the script, turning out to be more like a Scrooge-like setback, complete with disappointing performances that leave you wishing for a do-over.
And this is the part most people miss: while injuries and underperformance might seem like random misfortunes, they highlight a broader pattern in how the league manages its star players during the season's peak. For beginners trying to follow along, think of it this way—quarterbacks are like the engine of a football team. If the QB is hurt or not clicking, the whole offense sputters, much like a car with a faulty spark plug. This year, several key QBs are sidelined or playing below par, leading to games that feel flat and predictable. It's not just about one bad play; it's a ripple effect that dims the holiday spotlight. To illustrate, picture a team like the 49ers, who were Super Bowl contenders, now grappling with setbacks that echo throughout these matchups.
But let's not shy away from the debate: some fans argue that the NFL deliberately schedules weaker games around holidays to build hype for later playoffs, sacrificing early-season thrills for long-term drama. Others see it as a failure of roster management or even a conspiracy to keep viewership steady. What do you think—is this strategic planning or poor timing? And how does it affect the joy of watching football during family gatherings?
NFL
HAND CURATED
*
Neil Greenberg
Evaluating every NFL team as we head into Week 17
December 23, 2025
(https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2025/12/23/nfl-power-rankings-week-17/)
*
Neil Greenberg,
Chris Alcantara
and
Kati Perry
NFL playoff predictions: Projected wins and Super Bowl chances for all squads
December 23, 2025
(https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/interactive/2025/nfl-playoff-odds-standings-predictions-2025-26/)
*
Candace Buckner
Time to revisit the 49ers' Super Bowl aspirations once more
December 23, 2025
(https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2025/12/23/san-francisco-49ers-shanahan-jusczyk/)
As we wrap up, it's worth pondering: Should the NFL prioritize entertaining holiday games, even if it means risking more injuries, or focus on player health for the bigger picture? Do you agree that these Christmas matchups are a letdown, or do they still hold value in your eyes? Share your thoughts in the comments—let's discuss!
